AI power stocks fell by a third. Constellation and Vistra are raising their earnings outlooks
Two major US electricity producers serving data centers have lost more than 35% of their value from their yearly highs. Investors were spooked by Texas, where the new governor wants to halt data center construction. But the companies still have contracts lasting twenty years.

Key points
Shares of Constellation Energy and Vistra have fallen by more than a third from their yearly highs.
The sell-off was triggered by the Texas election, where the new governor promised to halt approvals for data centers.
Both companies are earning tens of percent more than last year and raising their earnings outlooks.
Vistra is significantly cheaper, but nearly half of its power plants are in Texas.
Amazon, Google and Meta have signed twenty-year contracts with both companies.
Artificial intelligence needs one thing above all: huge amounts of electricity. This simple idea drove up the share prices of Constellation Energy $CEG and Vistra $VST , two companies that operate nuclear and gas-fired power plants and sell electricity directly to tech giants.
But the past few weeks have looked very different. Constellation shares closed Friday, November 20, at $237.41, down 38% from their yearly high. Vistra ended at $115.25, down 37% from its peak. In Friday's trading alone, they fell by another roughly 6 and 7%.
Anyone looking at both companies as a chance to buy at a discount should know that each discount has a different reason and a different risk.
Texas did an about-face and the market panicked
The sell-off began back in October, as electricity prices in Texas weakened and the entire group of AI-linked stocks cooled. The real blow came after the November 3 election. In Texas, Democrat Gina Hinojosa defeated incumbent Governor Greg Abbott. During her campaign, she promised a moratorium on approving new data centers until lawmakers adopt rules to protect residents. The Texas legislature meets in January.
Texas is the largest and fastest-growing data center market in the US. Abbott had already announced a partial halt there, suspending the connection of new data centers to the grid in August.
The day after the election, Vistra shares fell 13.8%. That same day, KeyBanc downgraded the stock and withdrew its price target.
"This will be a negative surprise for investors."
Sophie Karp, KeyBanc analyst, on the Texas election result
Meanwhile, earnings are growing by tens of percent
What's interesting is that nothing has gone wrong in either company's business so far. Quite the opposite.
In its third-quarter report, Constellation posted net income of $1.84 billion, nearly double last year's $930 million. Adjusted earnings per share rose from $3.04 to $5.06, and the company raised its full-year outlook for the second time this year, now to $12.50 to $12.80 per share.
Vistra reported net income of $1.14 billion for the same period, compared with $652 million last year. EBITDA, or earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, jumped more than 50% to $2.38 billion. Vistra also raised its outlook for this year and expects further growth in 2027, to $7.7 to $8.5 billion.
Constellation Energy | Vistra | |
|---|---|---|
Share price (Nov. 20) | 237,41 USD | 115,25 USD |
Decline from yearly high | 38 % | 37 % |
Market value | 84 billion USD | 39 billion USD |
Generating capacity | approx. 55 GW | approx. 50 GW |
Share of capacity in Texas | approx. 26 % | approx. 46 % (before the Cogentrix acquisition) |
Share price relative to expected earnings | approx. 23 times | approx. 16 times |
Debt-to-equity ratio (end of 2025) | 0,6 | 4,0 |
Vistra: lower price, but exposed to Texas
At first glance, Vistra looks like the better bargain. Investors pay roughly 16 times its expected earnings over the next twelve months, compared with around 23 times for Constellation. In other words, for every dollar of future earnings, they pay almost a third less for Vistra.
The reason is obvious. Vistra is headquartered in Irving, Texas, and before its October purchase of Cogentrix gas-fired power plants, nearly half of its generating capacity was in Texas. About half of its third-quarter operating profit also came from its Texas segment. If data center construction there stalls, Vistra will feel it more than any other power producer.
Debt is another weakness. Vistra carries around $21 billion in debt and is leveraged several times more than Constellation relative to its equity. When things go well, debt multiplies shareholder returns. When they don't, it hurts twice as much.
There are two things on the other side of the scale. Vistra has locked in prices in advance for 98% of its electricity sales in 2027 and 78% in 2028, so short-term swings in the Texas market will have little impact on its earnings. And then there are the long-term contracts: Amazon $AMZN has secured up to 1,200 megawatts from the Comanche Peak nuclear plant for 20 years, while Meta $META has secured over 2,600 megawatts from three other nuclear units. These contracts are signed, and the moratorium on new projects does not affect them.
Constellation: pricier shares, fewer worries
Constellation is the largest operator of nuclear power plants in the US and is concentrated in the east of the country, where much of the next wave of data center construction is expected. Texas accounts for only about a quarter of its capacity, mainly thanks to its acquisition of Calpine this year.
Most importantly, it knows how to sign deals. In recent months, it signed a twenty-year contract with Google $GOOG that will enable more than $4.3 billion in investment to increase the output of eleven nuclear units, as well as a twenty-year contract with Amazon for 690 megawatts from the Calvert Cliffs plant. The US Department of Energy has also conditionally pledged it a loan of up to $5 billion to modernize its reactors.
Company chief Joe Dominguez called the post-election sell-off an overreaction during a conference call with analysts. He said Democrats care about economic growth and the jobs that data center construction brings.
"It's hard to imagine us stopping the work."
Joe Dominguez, CEO of Constellation Energy, on data center construction after the election
But there is a price for this peace of mind. Even after its decline, Constellation is valued more like a growth company than an electricity producer, and it has its own task on the balance sheet: integrating Calpine, which has also made it a major player in gas.
2027 will show who was right
Both stocks now hinge on the same question, but from opposite sides. Vistra is a bet that after the legislature's January session, Texas will tighten rules on data center construction rather than stop it. Constellation is the more expensive insurance in case things turn out worse.
Next year will bring several tough tests. Amazon is due to start taking power from Comanche Peak, Constellation plans to restart the reactor at the former Three Mile Island plant at the end of 2027, and Vistra will have to lock in prices for 2028, when more than a fifth of its generation is still unhedged.
Demand for electricity to power artificial intelligence hasn't disappeared. But tech companies are no longer the only ones deciding where and how quickly new data centers get built. Voters have a say too.